16 Nov To Your Health: Exercise Away a Bad Diet? Nope!
Welcome back to the series which offers a deep dive into the world of health, wellness, and disease prevention with Telluride local Dr. Alan Safdi.
Dr. Alan is a board-certified physician in Internal Medicine and Gastroenterology, a Fellow of the American College of Gastroenterology, and a respected leader in healthcare. His blogs have featured and will continue to showcase the most current information in his fields: health, wellness and longevity.
In this installment of “To Your Heath,” Dr. Alan tells an unvarnished truth: We can’t exercise away a bad diet or the hidden dangers of sugar and artificial sweeteners
Scroll down to read the salient details. (No podcast this week.)
And click here for more health and wellness podcasts from Dr. Alan.

Many years ago, I drank regular soft drinks. I also exercised frequently and considered myself quite healthy. I remember thinking it really didn’t matter if a soft drink contained 140 or 150 calories. I could simply burn off those calories during my next workout.
It seemed perfectly logical at the time. Calories consumed, calories burned. Problem solved.
But over the years, both my understanding of nutrition and my personal habits changed dramatically and, about 35 years ago, I began eliminating most added sugars and sugary products from my diet such as soft drinks, doughnuts, and other foods loaded with simple sugars. I began reading nutrition labels carefully and paying much closer attention to what I was putting into my body.
And something interesting happened. I gradually began feeling better and better. And perhaps even more remarkably, I stopped craving those foods.
Today, I have very little desire for sugary snacks or beverages. I continue to exercise every day, a habit I’ve maintained without interruption for more than nine years. But I’ve also come to appreciate that exercise, however valuable, is not a substitute for good nutrition.
My personal experience doesn’t prove that eliminating added sugars was responsible for every improvement I noticed. Nevertheless, my new regime fundamentally changed how I think about food and how I counsel my patients.
We cannot assume that burning off the calories in a sugary drink eliminates all its potential metabolic consequences.
The Lemonade Problem: Are You Really Making a Healthier Choice?
One of the most common conversations I have with patients begins with someone proudly announcing that they’ve stopped drinking soda.
That’s great news, and I congratulate them.
But then I ask a simple question: “What are you drinking instead?”
Frequently, the answer is lemonade, orange juice, apple juice, sweetened tea, sports drinks, or one of the many beverages marketed as natural or healthy.
Unfortunately, many of those drinks contain enormous amounts of sugar.
Consider “Simply Lemonade,” a popular beverage made with real lemon juice. According to its manufacturer’s nutrition information, an 8-ounce serving contains 27 grams of added sugar.
A 16-ounce glass contains approximately 54 grams of added sugar, the equivalent of 13½ teaspoons. By comparison, a standard 12-ounce can of Coca-Cola contains 39 grams of sugar.
In other words, someone who gives up a can of soda and replaces it with a large glass of lemonade may actually be consuming more sugar than they did before.
The American Heart Association recommends limiting added sugar to approximately 36 grams daily for men; 25 grams for women.
That one glass of lemonade exceeds the entire recommended daily amount for either.
And here’s another important distinction. Beverages labeled natural, organic, or made with real fruit are not necessarily low in sugar.
Even 100% fruit juice, which contains naturally occurring rather than added sugar, can deliver a substantial sugar load without most of the fiber found in whole fruit.
Eating an orange and drinking a large glass of orange juice are not nutritionally equivalent.
Whole fruit provides fiber, water, vitamins, and other beneficial compounds. It generally takes longer to consume and offers greater satiety. A glass of juice can deliver the sugar from several pieces of fruit in just a few minutes.
That is why I encourage patients to eat their fruit rather than routinely drink it.
What Does the Research Tell Us About Liquid Sugar?
A major 2025 systematic review and meta analysis published in Advances in Nutrition examined 29 prospective cohort studies investigating dietary sugar intake and the development of type 2 diabetes.
The findings were striking.
Each additional daily serving of sugary beverages was associated with approximately a 25% higher relative risk of developing type 2 diabetes.
Fruit juice was also associated with increased diabetes risk, although the relationship was smaller, approximately 5% per additional daily serving.
These results are associations from observational research, not proof that every extra serving directly causes diabetes. Nevertheless, the consistency of the findings across populations is concerning.
Interestingly, the investigators did not identify the same consistent association for sugars consumed in solid foods. That doesn’t mean added sugar in desserts is beneficial. It suggests that the form in which sugar is consumed, the foods accompanying it, and the overall dietary pattern are important.
Liquid sugar is particularly easy to consume in large quantities. Sugary beverages generally provide less satiety than solid foods, making it easier to consume excess calories without compensating by eating less later.
Large, repeated intakes of rapidly absorbed sugars can contribute to metabolic disturbances, including increased liver fat, insulin resistance, and abnormal lipid metabolism.
These processes are closely related to type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
And critically, they may occur even in people who are not obviously overweight.
A Worldwide Public Health Problem
Another major study, published in Nature Medicine in January 2025, examined the health burden associated with sugary beverages across 184 countries.
The investigators estimated that in 2020 alone, consumption of these beverages contributed to approximately 2.2 million new cases of type 2 diabetes and 1.2 million new cases of cardiovascular disease.
Those estimates represent nearly 10% of new type 2 diabetes cases and approximately 3% of new cardiovascular disease cases worldwide.
These were modeled estimates based on epidemiological research rather than individually confirmed cases caused by sugary drinks. Still, they highlight an enormous and potentially preventable public health burden.
We spend billions of dollars treating diabetes and cardiovascular disease. Yet one of the simplest preventive strategies may be encouraging people to stop consuming large quantities of sugar in beverages.
I believe this deserves far more attention in routine medical practice and public health education.
Could Excessive Sugar Consumption Also Affect Our Brains?
The relationship between nutrition and brain health is an especially exciting area of research.
We already recognize that diabetes, hypertension, obesity, and vascular disease can increase the risk of cognitive impairment and dementia. Now researchers are investigating whether unhealthy dietary patterns can also affect learning and memory more directly.
A 2026 systematic review and meta analysis published in Nutritional Neuroscience examined 27 animal studies evaluating the effects of diets high in fat and sugar on cognition and behavior. (The research was published online May 17, 2026, and appeared in the November 2026 journal issue.)
The researchers examined what happened when animals consuming unhealthy diets were switched back to healthier food.
Overall, memory performance improved compared with animals that continued consuming unhealthy diets. However, performance did not fully return to that of animals consistently maintained on healthy diets.
Some of the improvements varied according to the type of diet and cognitive testing used.
These findings are intriguing, but they require careful interpretation. Animal research cannot establish that sugar causes irreversible brain damage in humans.
Still, those results raise an important possibility: some consequences of prolonged unhealthy dietary habits can be more difficult to reverse than to prevent.
For me, the message is not that people who have eaten poorly are destined to develop dementia. Quite the opposite. Improving diet remains worthwhile at virtually any age.
But why wait until metabolic problems develop before making changes?
What About Artificial Sweeteners? Are They the Solution?
Many people have replaced sugary beverages with diet drinks containing artificial sweeteners.
From a metabolic standpoint, replacing a sugary beverage with a zero calorie alternative can substantially reduce sugar intake. For people with diabetes, that may be especially helpful.
However, emerging research raises questions about the long term consequences of routinely consuming low-calorie and zero-calorie sweeteners.
An important study originally published online in Neurology on September 3, 2025, followed approximately 12,800 Brazilian adults for eight years. The findings received renewed attention in an October 29, 2026 article titled “Six Popular Sugar Substitutes Linked to Faster Brain Aging.” The original scientific study underwent corrections, most recently on July 30, 2026.
Investigators examined seven sweeteners, including aspartame, saccharin, acesulfame potassium, erythritol, xylitol, sorbitol, and tagatose.
After accounting for several factors influencing cognitive health, researchers found that participants consuming the highest quantities of these sweeteners experienced a faster decline in cognitive test performance than those consuming the lowest amounts.
In the corrected analysis, the highest consumption group demonstrated a 63% faster relative rate of cognitive decline, equivalent to approximately 1.6 additional years of cognitive aging over the study period.
Six of the seven sweeteners were associated with faster decline in at least some measures of cognitive performance.
Importantly, the association was observed principally among participants younger than 60 and was not statistically significant in older participants.
We must also recognize that this was an observational study. It cannot establish that artificial sweeteners caused the cognitive decline. People consuming these products may differ in their underlying health, diabetes risk, dietary patterns, or other important characteristics.
Other research has not consistently found a relationship between artificially sweetened beverages and dementia.
Therefore, it would be premature to conclude that artificial sweeteners cause Alzheimer’s disease or directly injure the brain.
Nevertheless, I think the research raises a reasonable question.
Rather than continually replacing sugar with increasingly sweet alternatives, should we be trying to reduce our desire for sweetness in the first place?
That has certainly been my personal experience.
After decades of avoiding most products containing added sugar, I simply don’t miss them.
We Take Better Care of Our Cars Than Our Bodies
There is another comparison I frequently make when talking with patients.
Think about how carefully we maintain our automobiles.
We pay attention to the type of gasoline we use. We change the oil regularly. We follow maintenance schedules and worry about using the correct fluids.
We wouldn’t knowingly put something into our car’s engine that might damage it over time.
Yet many people pay remarkably little attention to what they put into their bodies every single day.
They may carefully research the best oil for their automobile, while drinking 50 or 60 grams of sugar in a beverage without ever reading the label.
The human body is infinitely more complex and valuable than any automobile. And, unlike a car, we cannot simply trade it in when decades of poor maintenance begin to cause problems.
I believe nutrition deserves the same attention we give to other important investments in our lives.
What I Recommend to My Patients
My advice is straightforward, and it doesn’t require an expensive diet program, supplements, or complicated nutritional calculations.
First, make water your primary beverage. Plain water, sparkling water, and water flavored with fresh lemon, lime, or other fruit are excellent choices.
Second, choose whole fruit instead of fruit juice whenever possible. You’ll receive the benefits of the fruit’s fiber and other nutrients while generally consuming it more slowly.
Third, read nutrition labels. Pay attention to both total sugars and added sugars. A product may look healthy on the front of the package while containing surprisingly large amounts of sugar.
Fourth, don’t assume that exercise cancels out poor dietary choices, although physical activity is one of the most powerful tools we have for preserving cardiovascular, metabolic, and cognitive health.
But exercise and nutrition work together. One doesn’t make the other unnecessary.
Fifth, gradually retrain your taste preferences. If you regularly consume sweetened drinks, try progressively reducing their sweetness. You may eventually discover, as I did, that you no longer desire the intensely sweet foods and beverages you once enjoyed.
Finally, follow a predominantly whole food dietary pattern emphasizing vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains, nuts, seeds, and healthy unsaturated fats.
There is no need to fear the natural sugars present in whole fruit or to eliminate every occasional dessert. The goal is to minimize habitual exposure to large amounts of added sugar, particularly in beverages.
Should Sugary Drinks Carry Warning Labels?
I believe we should seriously consider clearer warning labels on sugary beverages.
We have learned from tobacco prevention that public education and clear communication of health risks can influence behavior.
Sugary beverages are obviously not equivalent to cigarettes, and the magnitude and nature of their risks are different.
But when a product is associated with substantial and preventable chronic disease, consumers deserve to understand those risks.
At a minimum, I would like beverage labels to make the amount of sugar much more understandable, for example, expressing it prominently in teaspoons rather than relying solely on grams buried in a nutrition panel.
Imagine picking up a bottle of lemonade and immediately seeing that it contains 13 teaspoons of added sugar.
That might change a few purchasing decisions.
A Final Thought
I have spent much of my life encouraging patients to take an active role in maintaining their health.
The longer I practice medicine, the more convinced I become that the daily decisions we make about food, exercise, sleep, and other lifestyle habits are among the most important investments we can make in our future.
I still exercise every single day, and I believe strongly in the remarkable benefits of physical activity.
But one lesson I’ve learned over the past several decades is that we cannot exercise our way out of every consequence of unhealthy eating.
The good news is that changing our habits doesn’t necessarily mean sacrificing enjoyment. I eat a varied, satisfying diet and have no desire to return to the sugary foods and beverages I consumed years ago.
My challenge is simple.
For the next seven days, read the label on everything you drink. Calculate how much sugar you’re actually consuming. And ask yourself whether your supposedly healthy beverage is really much different from the soda you gave up.
You may be surprised by what you discover.
These days, I try to take as good care of my body as I do my cars. After all, I can always replace a car. I can’t replace my body.
Sometimes, one of the most powerful changes we can make for our long term health is not what we add to our diet, but what we eliminate, like sugary beverages.
Dr. Alan, more:
Dr. Alan Safdi is board-certified in Internal Medicine and in Gastroenterology and a Fellow of the American College of Gastroenterology. A proven leader in the healthcare arena, he has been featured on the national program, “Medical Crossfire” and authored or co-authored numerous medical articles and abstracts.
Dr. Alan is a long-time Telluride local, has been involved in grant-based and clinical research for four decades. He is passionate about disease prevention and wellness, not just fixing what has gone wrong.
He is also Chief Medical Officer Quadrant Health, partnered with and co-owned by Stanford University and Mayo Clinic.
No Comments